← FightWatchd
Judge dossier
Roy Silbert
Updated Jul 27, 2026
Total fights
73
Recorded scorecards
Fan match
0.0%
Same winner as fans
Compared fights
0
Had fan scorecards
Disputed fights
0
Flagged by users
Scorecard difference
How far this judge's score spread was from fan scorecards.
Typical gap
0
median pts
Big gap
0
90th pct pts
Decision types
How this judge's decision fights were classified.
Unanimous
57
Split
16
Majority
0
Home fighter bias
Does this judge score higher for fighters competing in their home country? Counts fights where exactly one fighter's nationality matches the event country.
+0.32pts
no clear home-country lean
37 qualifying fights · Positive = judge scores the home-country fighter higher than fan consensus on average.
Judged fights
Showing 51-73 of 73
Mike Ricci vs Colton Smith
The Ultimate Fighter 16 Finale
Dec 15, 2012 - Fight #2116
Score27-30
No fan card
Tim Elliott vs Jared Papazian
The Ultimate Fighter 16 Finale
Dec 15, 2012 - Fight #2107
Score30-25
No fan card